When the former defender assumed control as the club's boss in the winter, he faced little time to find his feet. A packed run of games translated to a gradual introduction to his group of players was impossible.
Pundits in Spain warned of the difficulties he would face, specifically managing a locker room packed with some of football's most prominent stars.
But building strong relationships with the players appeared not to worry the former Anfield full-back.
"It's not an aspect that troubles me much," Arbeloa stated at his inaugural news conference.
60 days since, he says those rapports are growing stronger and the results on the field are coming as a result.
Forging Relationships
In March, the Madrid boss guided his side to victories against teams led by world-class tacticians: the Portuguese manager's the Lisbon side, Pep Guardiola's City and the Argentine's Atletico.
Real Madrid remain a quartet of points behind La Liga pace-setters Barcelona, with a potentially decisive El Clasico in the spring, while their Champions League campaign rolls on with a last-eight tie against the German giants.
The team's performances are on the up and the relationships between the coach and squad are building.
"I'm getting to understand the individuals more and more," said the head coach following Real Madrid's 3-2 success against rivals Atletico Madrid last week.
"I arrived at a time when I almost had no time to observe the squad, to understand where they were at ease, and to witness how they mixed with one another."
He acknowledged the circumstances of his appointment posed unique obstacles.
"For me, it's difficult to come in the middle of the campaign and observe how the team works, and that's what has changed over these two months," he added.
"At present I know my players personally and professionally, where I can elicit the optimal performance from them, and where I can tweak things."
Praise for Vinicius
One player thriving under Arbeloa is the Brazilian winger.
He has been in the starting lineup for 16 of Arbeloa's 17 matches at the helm, with his output also rising markedly - he has netted 11 times under Arbeloa, versus managing just six in 27 outings under Xabi Alonso.
Arbeloa has prioritized restoring the forward's confidence, encouraging him to play freely and express himself rather than limiting him in terms of tactics.
"I am fortunate to have Vini, he's adored by the entire fanbase. We want to see the Vinicius who loves the game, who laughs, who dances… that is the Vini I want to see," Arbeloa said in his first news conference in charge.
That approach stands in opposition to rumors of strain under Alonso, with the forward being heard to say "I will leave this club" after being substituted in October's match against Barcelona.
Arbeloa has openly supported him, stating clearly he is has the total confidence by the coaches and the dressing room.
"He is among the most dangerous footballers, if not the most dangerous, in the world and he embodies what a Real Madrid star is," added Arbeloa.
Vinicius put discussions about his future at the club to one side last summer but, last week, he made his commitment clear.
"I am solely focused on this club and remaining here for a very long time," he told the media before Brazil's friendly match with France.
Valverde Regains Form Once More
Fede Valverde's form has also improved dramatically since Arbeloa took over.
During the tenure of the previous coach, he managed three goals and seven goal contributions from 31 games.
Since the manager's appointment, he has been named in the starting eleven for each of the 17 of his games, finding the net seven times and contributing five assists.
A primary cause has been a positional shift back into midfield.
During the former coach's spell, Valverde at times struggled to nail down a regular place in his natural role, being deployed in unusual positions such as full-back.
Although the move was partly due to injuries to teammates, Valverde's frustration was evident. "I was not made to be a right-back," he stated.
However, now, restored to his preferred position, the midfielder is excelling.
He has netted six goals in just a 30-day period, including a three-goal haul against City and a decisive strike in a 3–2 win over their city rivals.
Fresh Faces, More Potential?
Arbeloa's prior role as boss of the club's B team has made blending youth prospects into the senior side feel effortless, so it was expected to anticipate him to give promising youngsters minutes.
This was seen particularly when Real Madrid faced Elche recently and the coach provided opportunities to six youth team graduates.
One player, in particular, has swiftly made a name for himself as one of the manager's most exciting proteges.
Being only 18 years and 226 days old, he became the youngest footballer in the club's history to begin a match twice in the Champions League knockout stages, breaking a previous record by 10 days.
Asked what it meant to see several homegrown players on the field, he couldn't hide his joy.
"I believe I can be content after a night like tonight," he remarked.
"I was recently talking to two of them, who were the initial youngsters I coached when they were very young, and to be able to give them the chance to perform at the Santiago Bernabeu is a lifelong dream realized for me."
While the coach might be well-acquainted with the youth team players, he concedes injuries have restricted his exposure